115
Chemical contamination is combated by additives in the oil. Eventually, however, the additives are consumed and fail
to counteract the contaminants. At this point, the oil needs to be changed.
Physical contamination refers to metal particles and dirt in the oil. The metal particles come from wear between
moving parts. The dirt comes through the intakes, and a portion makes it past the rings. The problem is obvious in that
such particles will increase the wear on bearings and the like.
It is tempting to take comfort that the oil filter is preventing the particles from getting into the workings of the engine.
Unfortunately, it is not as effective as one could hope. The typical paper-element oil filter will catch particles down to
about 30 or 40 microns, but damage is caused by particles down to about 2.5 microns. These smaller particles build up
in the oil and pass right through the filter, cycling through the engine again and again.
The full-flow filter cannot be made with a tighter mesh because the restriction to oil flow would be too great. In
addition, if the filter gets clogged, either the element breaks open (dumping all the dirt into the engine), or the flow is
inhibited. Usually a relief valve is provided to allow oil to bypass a clogged filter, allowing crud of all sizes to circulate
through the engine.
There are two excellent ways to combat physical contamination. The first is by installing a bypass filter. A small
percentage of the pressurized oil from the outlet of the full-flow filter is diverted into a separate filter with a tight mesh
element to stop particles down to 2.5 microns, and from there right back into the sump. An orifice is provided to
prevent an excessive amount of oil from taking this route, which might starve the engine. If the filter gets plugged, no
problem -- the flow stops, and 100% of the oil goes through the galley as before. But as long as a small amount is
going through the bypass filter, within only a few minutes all of the engine oil is cycled through it and the amount of
suspended particles is greatly reduced.
The other method is essentially the same, except that the bypass filter is replaced by a centrifuge that causes the
particles to collect on the inside of a spinning cylinder. These are typically only available for larger engines.
These solutions are even better than changing oil at short intervals. Even with frequent oil changes, particles appear in
the oil immediately and continue to build up. The bypass filter, however, continuously keeps such particles from
causing engine wear.
Note that a bypass filter does not address chemical contamination. Such an installation would be effective at reducing
engine wear, but the oil needs to be changed at the same intervals to prevent the additives from failing.
An outfit called TF Purifiner (page 717) offers a package that includes a bypass filter system along with a small heater
that boils off water, fuel, and coolant to minimize the chemical contamination so the additives last longer.
Surfing the WWW, Mike Claus found that other products are available from Baker Precision Bearing (page 711), Fram
and Amsoil. “Fram offers an automotive by-pass filter in its product line that features a pleated-paper element and easy
“spin-on” replacement similar to original-equipment-type units. Ask for the Fram “PB50” with mounting hardware.
“Amsoil’s bypass unit is connected to the oil pressure sending unit and returns oil to the pan, thus requiring some
mechanical ability or the services of your mechanic for the initial installation. The company states that its bypass unit,
which employs a user replaceable, pressed-fiber element, refilters all the oil in an engine every five minutes, and keeps
it analytically sparkling clean for the (recommended maximum) element life of 25,000 miles! It even extracts and
contains any water that has (inevitably) condensed into the oil...which if allowed to remain in circulation will often
result in the formation of corrosive acids.”
Of course, one might immediately ask: if a bypass filter is such a good idea, why didn’t such a quality automobile as a
Jaguar come with one from the factory? Well, you have to consider the options the way the manufacturer does. The
lack of a bypass filter will not cause engine failure before some extended mileage, especially if the owner has been
paying the dealer for oil changes on a regular basis -- and even if the engine does fail due to dirty oil, the manufacturer
is not likely to incur any liability. The additional cost, multiplying the cost per car times the thousands of cars sold, is
significant. And the additional risk of failure -- one of the oil lines to a bypass filter blowing open or some such -- may
be more than the company wants to accept. Just having to tell prospective buyers that there are two oil filters that need
regular changing may be seen as a marketing disaster, especially in this era of drive-it-and-forget-it cars.